The digital marchamo and the dangers of building a surveillance infrastructure.

The Government of Costa Rica announced the Digital Marchamo project (the marchamo is the country’s annual vehicle circulation permit), which promises to modernize vehicle regulation and simplify services for citizens.
According to President Rodrigo Chaves Robles:
As the Presidential Office points out, RFID technology allows objects to be identified by radio frequency, so the digital marchamo will be able to capture hundreds of vehicles at once in order to feed a centralized system, which orchestrates citizen service systems and which can be read by the Traffic Police.
At the same time, Mónica Araya, Executive President of the National Insurance Institute (INS), stated that “with the signing of the decree declaring the project to be of public interest, we are confident that we will be able to keep moving forward with the support of many institutions for which this initiative will be of great help.”
From the above, we can conclude:
a) They are creating a centralized information system that will hold the information captured from vehicles traveling near the installed infrastructure.
b) The Traffic Police will be able to “read” this information, but it seems it will not be the only institution with access to it.
With this information, we need to analyze whether this represents a risk to citizens’ privacy.
Risks to citizens’ privacy.
The first thing to mention is that privacy is a concept that constantly adapts to society’s expectations of it, hence the importance of holding a deep and well-founded debate on these issues.
Unfortunately, in the 21st century Costa Rica has moved towards more transparent citizens, with less privacy, in relation to the State, since many officials have decided from behind a desk which information about Costa Ricans is published on the internet, without any public debate or any legislation authorizing it.
Many will say that some public institutions, led largely by the Supreme Electoral Tribunal (TSE), have undermined privacy in our country, but frankly that is a defeatist statement that does not reflect the reality of this field. We should not forget that in 2010 Mark Zuckerberg, CEO of Facebook, said that privacy was dead, but that after various scandals and extensive press coverage of privacy stories, in 2018 he said that the future is private. This should teach us a lesson about the importance of the role of citizens and the press in pushing towards a more private world.
For this reason, citizen participation in the debate and in these decisions should be encouraged, and the legal community and the media should spearhead the discussion of these issues, which must be grounded in technical facts and the truth.
This is not a discussion that should focus on the context of the current administration; it must be viewed with an eye to the future, because the technological and regulatory infrastructure we build today will be the foundation of the Costa Rica of the future.
How could the proposed infrastructure be abused?
For this analysis I start from the premise that the project has good intentions, aimed at laying the foundations for a Costa Rica with smart cities that provides better services to its citizens. However, privacy in our country has also been eroded with good intentions, so it is necessary to analyze every possibility of abuse in order to make decisions with full knowledge of the risks of technology-related projects.
As citizens, we should be concerned about two possibilities that open up with the installation of a surveillance infrastructure:
(a) A surveillance government uses it to control citizens. It must be clear that, even if this government has good intentions, once the infrastructure is installed it could be used by future governments to learn the routes, travel routines and location of Costa Ricans.
In addition, it should be taken into account that with the growth of artificial intelligence, all this information could be used to draw connections and perform analyses beyond human capacity, with a greater impact on citizens’ private lives.
For example, when the Constitutional Chamber decided that a judge’s authorization was not required for the Public Prosecutor’s Office to request a person’s call records, since there was no access to the content of the calls, it did not foresee that, under that same reasoning and without a court order, kölbi hands over its customers’ location history through a centralized computer system called SOLITEL.
So, in effect, this Digital Marchamo data, which may be shared with other institutions, could also be accessed without a court order.
(b) Personal data breaches by criminal groups, foreign intelligence agencies and snooping officials. As a general rule, if data is collected, there will be a risk of it being obtained by unauthorized third parties. In Costa Rica, most of the population has received calls in which criminals had obtained their information and used it to build their scams, so there is nothing to suggest it will be different this time.
Does the digital marchamo violate the constitutional framework? How is it similar to and different from the UPAD case?
It is important to note that, although the information contained in the chip is not sensitive information, it can be used for further processing and cross-referencing that may reveal sensitive information, and citizens have no options to protect their privacy without being exposed to fines for not having the marchamo chip installed in their vehicles. In the future, they could even create fines for interfering with the chip’s signal.
The difference between the two cases is that this project involves installing an infrastructure that would allow the population to be monitored and controlled if additional analysis is carried out. The UPAD, on the other hand, was a program that centralized data from various sources, including some containing sensitive information, which made it possible to look up any individual’s information without restriction once it was in its possession.
However, the similarity is that, without an enabling law, both cases infringe fundamental rights, which undoubtedly runs counter to the principles of statutory reserve and legality, and also violates the Law on the Protection of Persons with regard to the Processing of their Personal Data.
It should be noted that we still have relatively little information, so this is an issue that will continue to develop.
Originally published in Spanish.